Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater

A wide range of dyes are being disposed in water bodies from several industrial runoff and the quantity is rapidly increasing over the years. From an environmental safety point of view, it is urgent to improve the removal process of dyes. It is important to understand the stochastic and highly redun...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Journal of Cleaner Production
Main Author: Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
Format: Review
Language:English
Published: Elsevier Ltd 2023
Online Access:https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85145195702&doi=10.1016%2fj.jclepro.2022.135522&partnerID=40&md5=3c478ba33761b38a46653180b8903584
id 2-s2.0-85145195702
spelling 2-s2.0-85145195702
Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
2023
Journal of Cleaner Production
385

10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.135522
https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85145195702&doi=10.1016%2fj.jclepro.2022.135522&partnerID=40&md5=3c478ba33761b38a46653180b8903584
A wide range of dyes are being disposed in water bodies from several industrial runoff and the quantity is rapidly increasing over the years. From an environmental safety point of view, it is urgent to improve the removal process of dyes. It is important to understand the stochastic and highly redundant behavior of the process of dye removal (DR) in wastewater treatment. This leads to better utilization of Machine Learning (ML) models for both optimization as well as prediction of the DR process efficiency. In this review, 200 papers (Years, 2006–2021) have been systematically reviewed from the Web of Science and Scopus-indexed journals, covering a total of 84 journals. All applied ML models have been thoroughly studied in the review and analyzed in terms of their architecture setup, hyper-parameters selection, performance, advantages, and disadvantages. A wide range of optimization methods for hyper-parameters tuning were analyzed and discussed scientifically. Explicit information about the data sizes, splitting structure for training-validation-testing along with input and output selection approaches have been logically reviewed and discussed. Data availability, transparency, and reusability have been reported adequately. Various software for data-driven modeling have been discussed with their pros and cons. Trends in statistical evaluators (among about 60 types) have been discussed with their pros and cons including their sensitivity with the data fluctuations. Moreover, the most popular performance metrics have reported. In addition, the DR mechanism has reviewed and discussed inclusively. Extensive media used for the decolorization were discussed thoroughly, including their physical and chemical characteristics, along with feasibility and equilibrium data based on Langmuir model. The cost of the applied media in the decolorization process reported adequately. Finally, the research gap and future road map of the next 5 years, which bridge the gap of the domain are scientifically drafted along with the limitations. This critical review not only provides the appraisal of growth of DR research integrated with ML in the last couple of decades but also scouts the potential studies where all experimental, chemical and modeling processes should be taken under consideration. © 2022 Elsevier Ltd
Elsevier Ltd
9596526
English
Review

author Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
spellingShingle Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
author_facet Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
author_sort Bhagat S.K.; Pilario K.E.; Babalola O.E.; Tiyasha T.; Yaqub M.; Onu C.E.; Pyrgaki K.; Falah M.W.; Jawad A.H.; Yaseen D.A.; Barka N.; Yaseen Z.M.
title Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
title_short Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
title_full Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
title_fullStr Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
title_full_unstemmed Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
title_sort Comprehensive review on machine learning methodologies for modeling dye removal processes in wastewater
publishDate 2023
container_title Journal of Cleaner Production
container_volume 385
container_issue
doi_str_mv 10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.135522
url https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85145195702&doi=10.1016%2fj.jclepro.2022.135522&partnerID=40&md5=3c478ba33761b38a46653180b8903584
description A wide range of dyes are being disposed in water bodies from several industrial runoff and the quantity is rapidly increasing over the years. From an environmental safety point of view, it is urgent to improve the removal process of dyes. It is important to understand the stochastic and highly redundant behavior of the process of dye removal (DR) in wastewater treatment. This leads to better utilization of Machine Learning (ML) models for both optimization as well as prediction of the DR process efficiency. In this review, 200 papers (Years, 2006–2021) have been systematically reviewed from the Web of Science and Scopus-indexed journals, covering a total of 84 journals. All applied ML models have been thoroughly studied in the review and analyzed in terms of their architecture setup, hyper-parameters selection, performance, advantages, and disadvantages. A wide range of optimization methods for hyper-parameters tuning were analyzed and discussed scientifically. Explicit information about the data sizes, splitting structure for training-validation-testing along with input and output selection approaches have been logically reviewed and discussed. Data availability, transparency, and reusability have been reported adequately. Various software for data-driven modeling have been discussed with their pros and cons. Trends in statistical evaluators (among about 60 types) have been discussed with their pros and cons including their sensitivity with the data fluctuations. Moreover, the most popular performance metrics have reported. In addition, the DR mechanism has reviewed and discussed inclusively. Extensive media used for the decolorization were discussed thoroughly, including their physical and chemical characteristics, along with feasibility and equilibrium data based on Langmuir model. The cost of the applied media in the decolorization process reported adequately. Finally, the research gap and future road map of the next 5 years, which bridge the gap of the domain are scientifically drafted along with the limitations. This critical review not only provides the appraisal of growth of DR research integrated with ML in the last couple of decades but also scouts the potential studies where all experimental, chemical and modeling processes should be taken under consideration. © 2022 Elsevier Ltd
publisher Elsevier Ltd
issn 9596526
language English
format Review
accesstype
record_format scopus
collection Scopus
_version_ 1809678017812758528