Consensus and Diversity in the Management of Varicocele for Male Infertility: Results of a Global Practice Survey and Comparison with Guidelines and Recommendations

Consensus and Diversity in the Management of Varicocele for Male Infertility: Results of a Global Practice Survey and Comparison with Guidelines and Recommendations

Purpose: Varicocele is a common problem among infertile men. Varicocele repair (VR) is frequently performed to improve semen parameters and the chances of pregnancy. However, there is a lack of consensus about the diagnosis, indications for VR and its outcomes. The aim of this study was to explore g...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:World Journal of Men's Health
Main Authors: Shah R.; Agarwal A.; Kavoussi P.; Rambhatla A.; Saleh R.; Cannarella R.; Harraz A.M.; Boitrelle F.; Kuroda S.; Hamoda T.A.-A.A.-M.; Zini A.; Ko E.; Calik G.; Toprak T.; Kandil H.; Gül M.; Bakırcıoğlu M.E.; Parekh N.; Russo G.I.; Tadros N.; Kadioglu A.; Arafa M.; Chung E.; Rajmil O.; Dimitriadis F.; Malhotra V.; Salvio G.; Henkel R.; Le T.V.; Sogutdelen E.; Vij S.; Alarbid A.; Gudeloglu A.; Tsujimura A.; Calogero A.E.; El Meliegy A.; Crafa A.; Kalkanli A.; Baser A.; Hazir B.; Giulioni C.; Cho C.-L.; Ho C.C.K.; Salzano C.; Zylbersztejn D.S.; Tien D.M.B.; Pescatori E.; Borges E., Jr.; Serefoglu E.C.; Saïs-Hamza E.; Huyghe E.; Ceyhan E.; Caroppo E.; Castiglioni F.; Bahar F.; Gokalp F.; Lombardo F.; Gadda F.; Duarsa G.W.K.; Pinggera G.-M.; Busetto G.M.; Balercia G.; Cito G.; Blecher G.; Franco G.; Liguori G.; Elbardisi H.; Keskin H.; Lin H.; Taniguchi H.; Park H.J.; Ziouziou I.; de la Rosette J.; Hotaling J.; Ramsay J.; Molina J.M.C.; Lo K.L.; Bocu K.; Khalafalla K.; Bowa K.; Okada K.; Nagao K.; Chiba K.; Hakim L.; Makarounis K.; Hehemann M.; Peña M.R.; Falcone M.; Bendayan M.; Martinez M.; Timpano M.; Altan M.; Fode M.; Al-Marhoon M.S.; Gilani M.A.S.; Soebadi M.A.; Gherabi N.; Sofikitis N.; Kahraman O.; Birowo P.; Kothari P.; Sindhwani P.; Javed Q.; Ambar R.F.; Kosgi R.; Ghayda R.A.; Adriansjah R.; Condorelli R.A.; La Vignera S.; Micic S.; Kim S.H.K.; Fukuhara S.; Ahn S.T.; Mostafa T.; Ong T.A.; Takeshima T.; Amano T.; Barrett T.; Arslan U.; Karthikeyan V.S.; Atmoko W.; Yumura Y.; Yuan Y.; Kato Y.; Jezek D.; Cheng B.K.-C.; Hatzichristodoulou G.; Dy J.; Castañé E.R.; El-Sakka A.I.; Nguyen Q.; Sarikaya S.; Boeri L.; Tan R.; Moussa M.A.; El-Assmy A.; Alali H.; Alhathal N.; Osman Y.; Perovic D.; Sajadi H.; Akhavizadegan H.; Vučinić M.; Kattan S.; Kattan M.S.; Mogharabian N.; Phuoc N.H.V.; Ngoo K.S.; Alkandari M.H.; Alsuhaibani S.; Sokolakis I.; Babaei M.; King M.S.; Diemer T.; Gava M.M.; Henrique R.; Spinola e Silva R.; Paul G.M.; Mierzwa T.C.; Glina S.; Siddiqi K.; Wu H.; Wurzacher J.; Farkouh A.; Son H.; Minhas S.; Lee J.; Magsanoc N.; Capogrosso P.; Albano G.J.; Lewis S.E.M.; Jayasena C.N.; Alvarez J.G.; Teo C.; Smith R.P.; Chua J.B.M.; Jensen C.F.S.; Parekattil S.; Finelli R.; Durairajanayagam D.; Karna K.K.; Ahmed A.; Evenson D.; Umemoto Y.; Puigvert A.; Çeker G.; Colpi G.M.; Rolitsky S.; Bouzouita A.; Shokeir A.; Asci A.; Bouker A.; Adamyan A.; Avoyan A.E.; Palani A.; Aghamajidi A.; Eze B.; Noegroho B.S.; Purnomo B.; Erkan B.K.; Zilaitiene B.; Kulaksiz D.; Kafetzis D.; Lee D.S.; Stember D.; Evgeni E.; Alhajeri F.; Finocchi F.; Colombo F.; Tsangaris G.; Sallam H.N.; Acosta H.; Rosas I.M.; Kirkman-Brown J.; Shin J.I.; Sonksen J.; Dong J.; Marmar J.; Moreno-Sepulveda J.; Seo J.T.; Aydos K.; Kesari K.K.; Trost L.; Jenkins L.; Rocco L.; Darbandi M.; Simopoulou M.; Alves M.; Sabbaghian M.; Tavalaee M.; Razi M.; Duran M.B.; Nago M.; Elkhouly M.; Khalili M.; Nasr-Esfahani M.H.; Kamath M.S.; Ugur M.R.; Park N.C.; Cruz N.; Garrido N.; Sodeifi N.; Al Khalidi N.; Shoshany O.; Satyagraha P.; Drakopoulos P.; Vogiatzi P.; Dolati P.; Das P.; Chiu P.K.-F.; Tsioulou P.A.; Patel P.; Singh R.; Kaiyal R.S.; Santos F.; Dada R.; Brodjonegoro S.; Banihani S.A.; Schon S.; Darbandi S.; Gunes S.; Homa S.; Mutambirwa S.; Roychoudhury S.; Diaz S.I.L.; Gopalakrishnan S.; Krawetz S.; Jindal S.; Avidor-Reiss T.; Lin T.Y.; Kumar V.; Ibrahim W.; Kerkeni W.; Woo W.; Morimoto Y.; Cheng Y.-S.
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Korean Society for Sexual Medicine and Andrology 2022
Online Access:https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85134651253&doi=10.5534%2fwjmh.220048&partnerID=40&md5=d6b6ed00768c2dca54124a8ae8fef5ff
Description
Summary:Purpose: Varicocele is a common problem among infertile men. Varicocele repair (VR) is frequently performed to improve semen parameters and the chances of pregnancy. However, there is a lack of consensus about the diagnosis, indications for VR and its outcomes. The aim of this study was to explore global practice patterns on the management of varicocele in the context of male infertility. Materials and Methods: Sixty practicing urologists/andrologists from 23 countries contributed 382 multiple-choice-questions pertaining to varicocele management. These were condensed into an online questionnaire that was forwarded to clinicians involved in male infertility management through direct invitation. The results were analyzed for disagreement and agreement in practice patterns and, compared with the latest guidelines of international professional societies (American Urological Association [AUA], American Society for Reproductive Medicine [ASRM], and European Association of Urology [EAU]), and with evidence emerging from recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Additionally, an expert opinion on each topic was provided based on the consensus of 16 experts in the field. Results: The questionnaire was answered by 574 clinicians from 59 countries. The majority of respondents were urologists/uro-andrologists. A wide diversity of opinion was seen in every aspect of varicocele diagnosis, indications for repair, choice of technique, management of sub-clinical varicocele and the role of VR in azoospermia. A significant proportion of the responses were at odds with the recommendations of AUA, ASRM, and EAU. A large number of clinical situations were identified where no guidelines are available. Conclusions: This study is the largest global survey performed to date on the clinical management of varicocele for male infertility. It demonstrates: 1) a wide disagreement in the approach to varicocele management, 2) large gaps in the clinical practice guidelines from professional societies, and 3) the need for further studies on several aspects of varicocele management in infertile men. Copyright, © 2022 Korean Society for Sexual Medicine and Andrology
ISSN:22874208
DOI:10.5534/wjmh.220048

Similar Items

  • Impact of Varicocele Repair on Semen Parameters in Infertile Men: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    by: Agarwal A.; Cannarella R.; Saleh R.; Boitrelle F.; Gül M.; Toprak T.; Salvio G.; Arafa M.; Russo G.I.; Harraz A.M.; Singh R.; Garrido N.; Abdel-Meguid Hamoda T.A.-A.; Rambhatla A.; Kavoussi P.; Kuroda S.; Çalik G.; Saini P.; Ceyhan E.; Dimitriadis F.; Henkel R.; Crafa A.; Palani A.; Duran M.B.; Maziotis E.; Saïs É.; Bendayan M.; Darbandi M.; Le T.V.; Gunes S.; Tsioulou P.; Sengupta P.; Hazir B.; Çeker G.; Darbandi S.; Durairajanayagam D.; Aghamajidi A.; Alkhalidi N.; Sogutdelen E.; Leisegang K.; Alarbid A.; Ho C.C.K.; Malhotra V.; Finocchi F.; Crisóstomo L.; Kosgi R.; ElBardisi H.; Zini A.; Birowo P.; Colpi G.; Park H.J.; Serefoglu E.C.; Nguyen Q.; Ko E.; de la Rosette J.; Pinggera G.M.; Nguyen H.V.P.; Kandil H.; Shah R.
    Published: (2022)
  • Antisperm Antibody Testing: A Comprehensive Review of Its Role in the Management of Immunological Male Infertility and Results of a Global Survey of Clinical Practices
    by: Gupta S.; Sharma R.; Agarwal A.; Boitrelle F.; Finelli R.; Farkouh A.; Saleh R.; Abdel-Meguid T.A.-A.; Gül M.; Zilaitiene B.; Ko E.; Rambhatla A.; Zini A.; Leisegang K.; Kuroda S.; Henkel R.; Cannarella R.; Palani A.; Cho C.-L.; Ho C.C.K.; Zylbersztejn D.S.; Pescatori E.; Chung E.; Dimitriadis F.; Pinggera G.-M.; Busetto G.M.; Balercia G.; Salvio G.; Colpi G.M.; Çeker G.; Taniguchi H.; Kandil H.; Park H.J.; Rosas I.M.; de la Rosette J.; Cardoso J.P.G.; Ramsay J.; Alvarez J.; Molina J.M.C.; Khalafalla K.; Bowa K.; Tremellen K.; Evgeni E.; Rocco L.; Peña M.G.R.; Sabbaghian M.; Martinez M.; Arafa M.; Al-Marhoon M.S.; Tadros N.; Garrido N.; Rajmil O.; Sengupta P.; Vogiatzi P.; Kavoussi P.; Birowo P.; Kosgi R.; Bani-Hani S.; Micic S.; Parekattil S.; Jindal S.; Le T.V.; Mostafa T.; Toprak T.; Morimoto Y.; Malhotra V.; Aghamajidi A.; Durairajanayagam D.; Shah R.
    Published: (2022)
  • Controversy and Consensus on Indications for Sperm DNA Fragmentation Testing in Male Infertility: A Global Survey, Current Guidelines, and Expert Recommendations
    by: Agarwal A.; Farkouh A.; Saleh R.; Hamoda T.A.-A.A.-M.; Harraz A.M.; Kavoussi P.; Arafa M.; Salvio G.; Rambhatla A.; Toprak T.; Gül M.; Phuoc N.H.V.; Boitrelle F.; Birowo P.; Ghayda R.A.; Cannarella R.; Kuroda S.; Durairajanayagam D.; Zini A.; Wyns C.; Sarikaya S.; Tremellen K.; Mostafa T.; Sokolakis I.; Evenson D.P.; Henkel R.; Zohdy W.; Chung E.; Ziouziou I.; Falcone M.; Russo G.I.; Al-Hashimi M.; Calogero A.E.; Ko E.; Colpi G.; Lewis S.; Serefoglu E.C.; Bahar F.; Martinez M.; Nguyen Q.; Ambar R.F.; Bakircioglu M.E.; Kandil H.; Mogharabian N.; Sabbaghian M.; Taniguchi H.; Tsujimura A.; Sajadi H.; Ibrahim W.; Atmoko W.; Vogiatzi P.; Gunes S.; Gilani M.A.S.; Roychoudhury S.; Güngör N.D.; Hakim L.; Adriansjah R.; Kothari P.; Jindal S.; Amar E.; Park H.J.; Long T.Q.T.; Homa S.; Karthikeyan V.S.; Zilaitiene B.; Rosas I.M.; Marino A.; Pescatori E.; Ozer C.; Akhavizadegan H.; Garrido N.; Busetto G.M.; Adamyan A.; Al-Marhoon M.; Elbardisi H.; Dolati P.; Darbandi M.; Darbandi S.; Balercia G.; Pinggera G.-M.; Micic S.; Ho C.C.K.; Moussa M.; Preto M.; Zenoaga-Barbăroșie C.; Smith R.P.; Kosgi R.; de la Rosette J.; El-Sakka A.I.; Abumelha S.M.; Mierzwa T.C.; Ong T.A.; Banihani S.A.; Bowa K.; Fukuhara S.; Boeri L.; Danacıoğlu Y.O.; Gokalp F.; Selim O.M.; Cho C.-L.; Tadros N.N.; Ugur M.R.; Ozkent M.S.; Chiu P.; Kalkanli A.; Khalafalla K.; Vishwakarma R.B.; Finocchi F.; Andreadakis S.; Giulioni C.; Çeker G.; Ceyhan E.; Malhotra V.; Yilmaz M.; Timpano M.; Barrett T.L.; Kim S.H.K.; Ahn S.-T.; Giacone F.; Palani A.; Duarsa G.W.K.; Kadioglu A.; Gadda F.; Zylbersztejn D.S.; Aydos K.; Kulaksız D.; Gupte D.; Calik G.; Karna K.K.; Drakopoulos P.; Baser A.; Kumar V.; Molina J.M.C.; Rajmil O.; Ferreira R.H.; Leonardi S.; Avoyan A.; Sogutdelen E.; Franco G.; Ramsay J.; Ramirez L.; Shah R.; Gherabi N.; Kahraman O.; Trotta C.; Rocco L.; Ngoo K.S.; Sallam H.; El Meliegy A.; Alhathal N.; Chien K.; Lee J.; Le T.V.
    Published: (2023)
  • Appendectomy and asthma: a search for an association in older subjects
    by: Leong K.K.; Zim M.A.M.; Botross N.P.; Kun T.Y.; Nordin N.B.; Ramachandran V.; Woi S.P.; Pemasiri W.D.R.H.; Thin C.S.; Yee P.W.Y.; Yi K.J.; Wei S.L.S.; Ling M.C.P.; Chien R.G.G.; Cai C.Z.; Kok Y.Q.; Loh H.Y.; Su E.J.E.; Shamsuddin A.R.; Tarekh N.A.M.; Sood S.
    Published: (2024)
  • Rationale, Design and Baseline Characteristics of Participants in the Cardiovascular Outcomes for People Using Anticoagulation Strategies (COMPASS) Trial
    by: Bosch J.; Eikelboom J.W.; Connolly S.J.; Bruns N.C.; Lanius V.; Yuan F.; Misselwitz F.; Chen E.; Diaz R.; Alings M.; Lonn E.M.; Widimsky P.; Hori M.; Avezum A.; Piegas L.S.; Bhatt D.L.; Branch K.R.H.; Probstfield J.L.; Liang Y.; Liu L.; Zhu J.; Maggioni A.P.; Lopez-Jaramillo P.; O'Donnell M.; Fox K.A.A.; Kakkar A.; Parkhomenko A.N.; Ertl G.; Störk S.; Keltai K.; Keltai M.; Ryden L.; Dagenais G.R.; Pogosova N.; Dans A.L.; Lanas F.; Commerford P.J.; Torp-Pedersen C.; Guzik T.J.; Verhamme P.B.; Vinereanu D.; Kim J.-H.; Ha J.-W.; Tonkin A.M.; Varigos J.D.; Lewis B.S.; Felix C.; Yusoff K.; Steg P.G.; Aboyans V.; Metsarinne K.P.; Anand S.S.; Hart R.G.; Lamy A.; Moayyedi P.; Leong D.P.; Sharma M.; Yusuf S.
    Published: (2017)